Toll Free 1.888.487.6754
International 001.734.205.5870
Call Us Today!

Start Searching for Your Vacation Property

Search Our 1526 Sanibel and Captiva Rentals

Rental Type:    


Captiva Island Vacation Rentals – Sanibel Rentals

We offer hundreds of Sanibel – Captiva, FL rentals from luxury Captiva Island beach rentals to quaint Sanibel cottage rentals. For your next vacation stay in a Captiva Island, luxury beach home with pool or choose a Sanibel, beach condo with a views of the Gulf of Mexico. Why choose a Captiva Island vacation destination over all the other wonderful beach resorts in South Florida? It's simple! Captiva Island provides a Caribbean style tropical Island getaway without ever having to leave the United States. Low key Captiva provides visitors with an abundance of sapphire blue, crystal clear, waters and miles upon miles of white powder sand making this the number one beach Destination in South Florida. No spring break crowds here. This perfect little piece of paradise relishes in its understated yet exclusive Island appeal, offering visitors privacy, high end rental accommodations and secluded unspoiled beaches.

Sanibel Island or Captiva Island Vacation – Which is better?

Our Destination Experts are constantly asked which is the best beach location, Sanibel or Captiva? Our professional answer is that your accommodation preferences will determine the location. There are however some subtle differences in their appeal...

Captiva Island is a mere 5 miles long and possesses a definite tropical island feel. There are only a handful of restaurants and shops located in the "Village" area so visitors tend to entertain and cook in their spacious, fully equipped Captiva beach homes. When the mood strikes take a short drive and eat out at one of Sanibel's many local dining establishments. Captiva accommodations are available weekly but have a strict Saturday check-in requirement. Rentals are typically a bit more expensive than Sanibel accommodations which are usually smaller bay or beach side accommodations.

Sunny Sanibel Island is a strikingly beautiful barrier island with some of the best shelling beaches in the world. Larger than its little sister Captiva, Sanibel offers an abundance of beach condos and smaller homes that are family friendly and more competitively priced. Where Captiva shuts down pretty early Sanibel has lots of dining, shopping and activities going on late into the evening.

Sanibel and Captiva Island Vacation Rentals versus Hotel Accommodation

Our Professionally managed Captiva Vacation Rentals and Sanibel Rentals provide visitors the luxury of staying in a private beach rental home or condo at a fraction of the cost of reserving hotel rooms. Unlike many South Florida locations that have built high rise beach condos and resorts along their shoreline, Captiva Island has retained an abundance of direct beach front homes with private pools and high end amenities. If you are looking for a beach house in south Florida, Captiva offers by far the widest selection.

For those visitors looking at a smaller beach accommodation Sanibel has a wide selection of low rise condos and cozy beach side cottages. Call a Coast 2 Coast Captiva destination expert today to discuss the wide variety of vacation rental options available. 888-487-6754

Why use Coast 2 Coast Vacation Rentals?

We are the best at what we do! Coast 2 Coast Vacation Rentals Inc. is considered the defining force in the vacation rental industry, providing its customers with thousands of professionally managed and privately owned vacation rental homes, condo and villa options. Once you consult with one of our highly knowledgeable destination experts you will delight in the array of accommodation options available for you. Coast 2 Coasts first rate service and support takes the “work out of your vacation” from the early planning stage through to check in and beyond.

To enhance you vacation experience even further, Coast 2 Coast provides extensive, complimentary concierge services ensuring your visit is just perfect. “We like our customers to hit the ground running and not waste valuable vacation time familiarizing themselves with the area. Our guests are 'Our VIPs' we can have their golf and dinner reservations all taken care off before they even arrive.” Sonia Kaufman, President, Coast 2 Coast Vacation Rentals

Whether you are looking for a luxury vacation rental or a more modest cottage or condo, Coast 2 Coast is your one stop viewing shop to all Sanibel and Captiva Vacation Accommodations. Did we mention the HUGE inventory of properties we have to offer you? We represent close to 800 Captiva and Sanibel rentals! Let us help you choose the perfect rental accommodation.

Call a Coast 2 Coast Rental Destination Expert at 888-487-6754 available from 8:00 am - 9:00 pm 7 days per week.

Our Captiva and Sanibel Destination Experts can be reached at 888-487-6754 and can answer your questions about our hundreds of Sanibel and Captiva rentals; they are highly knowledgeable about the area as well as the specific properties available. New additions to our Sanibel & Captiva rental properties arrive daily and may not yet be on the website - call today to learn about these new additions!

Call Us Today!

Call a Coast 2 Coast Representative Today!

Call Now 888.487.6754 and speak directly with a Coast 2 Coast Destination Expert.

From your Very First Call our Vacation Rental Guests Receive our Complimentary Concierge Service.

Selecting that Special Vacation Location and Property Type is the first step before reserving a Vacation Home or Condo.

Call 8.00am- 9pm EST and discuss all area amenities and accommodation options available for your dates.

From Our Customers

“I just wanted to say thanks for all your assistance with our vacation planning this Spring. In the end, all turned out well and we loved Siesta Key.”
- Karen K, Indianapolis, IN
[ more testimonials ]

Coast 2 Coast Travel Magazine

Learn about vacation rental specials, promotions, and new properties in all high end ski and beach vacation resort areas.